Thursday, June 28, 2007
Othello & Much Ado About Nothing
The power of suggestion upon our mind is very strong. This power can cause us to believe we see things that do not actually exist or make us feel things that we never intended to feel. Although on the surface, Shakespeare’s two plays, Othello and Much Ado About Nothing, do not have anything in common, one being a terrible tragedy, the other being a popular comedy, I find that the power of suggestion speaks strongly in both plays. “Suggestion” is defined in one way in the dictionary as “… the process of inducing a thought, sensation, or action in a receptive person without using persuasion and without giving rise to reflection in the recipient.” In the first play, this power of suggestion is used to destroy. In the second, it is used to create.
Our minds are powerful and do not know the difference between what is real and what is not. “The power of suggestion is based on the psychological mechanism that whatever the subconscious accepts, it acts on.” (121Hypnosis.com article) While Othello is praised for being a man of much strength and beloved by many for his heroic war actions, he proves to be susceptible to the power of suggestion by listening to the insinuating remarks made by his trusted comrade, Iago, about Desdemona, Othello’s wife. Perhaps Desdemona’s father, upon learning that his daughter had wed Othello, planted the first subconscious doubts, when he said to Othello,
“She has deceived her father, and may thee.”
(p. 1119, The Complete Works, William Shakespeare)
Throughout the play, Iago simply suggests things to Othello. He has no proof for these things, but he sets up scenes to “prove” his suggestions are true. To take revenge on Othello for not promoting Iago to officer, he plans a trap to destroy both Cassio, who received the officer’s promotion, and Othello.
“He [Othello] holds me well; the better shall my purpose work on him.
Cassio’s a proper man: let me see now; to get his place, and to plume up
my will in double knavery, how, how? Let’s see:--- after some time to abuse Othello’s ear that he is too familiar with his wife---he hath a person, and a smooth dispose, to be suspected; framed to make women false. The moor is of a free and open nature… and will as tenderly be led by the nose as asses are.”
(p. 1120, The Complete Works, William Shakespeare)
Initially, Othello sees none of this. There is nothing to see that is amiss. Othello deeply loves Desdemona and knows she will not betray him. And Othello loves Cassio, his friend. Ironically, Othello trusts Iago. It is this love and trust that Iago uses to defeat Othello. Iago plans to “..put the Moor at least into a jealousy so strong that judgment cannot cure.” (p.1124)
Iago begins his treachery by seizing upon Cassio’s weakness for drinking. He convinces Cassio to drink more than he should, causing Cassio to become drunk and fight with other soldiers. After assessing the situation, Othello responds,
“Cassio, I love thee; but never more be officer of mine” (p. 1127)
Thus, Iago’s destruction has begun.
Iago convinces Cassio to apply to Desdemona for help in receiving his job back. As Cassio works with Desdemona, Iago subtly plants thoughts and doubts into Othello’s mind.
“…I cannot think it [was Cassio] that he would steal away so guilty-like,
seeing you coming (p.1129)….Look to your wife; observe her well with Cassio…She did deceive her father, marrying you; and when she seemed to shake and fear your looks, she loved them most (p. 1131)….”
Othello begins to “see” Desdemona’s infidelity and his anger grows.
In the end, Othello’s jealousy indeed proves to be “so strong that judgment cannot cure.” He kills Desdemona in a jealous rage. Upon discovering the truth, that Desdemona did only love Othello, he kills himself. With words alone, Iago’s plan to destroy Othello has worked.
In Much Ado About Nothing, we meet Beatrice and Benedick, two friends who enjoy taunting and teasing one another to see who can outwit the other.
“…There is a kind of merry war betwixt Signior Benedick and her;
They never meet but there is a skirmish of wit between them.”
(p. 127, The Complete Works, William Shakespeare)
Neither Beatrice nor Benedick plan to marry anyone, as they prefer themselves to the company of the opposite sex. Beatrice explains in simple terms her requirements for a husband,
“He that hath a beard is more than a youth; and he that hath no beard is
less than a man; and he that is more than a youth is not for me and he
that is less than a man, I am not for him.”
(p. 131, The Complete Works, William Shakespeare)
Benedick also contemplates what qualities he admires in a wife,
“One woman is fair; yet I am well; another is wise; yet I am well;
another virtuous; yet I am well, but till all graces be in one woman,
one woman shall not come in my grace. Rich she shall be, that’s certain;
wise, or I’ll none; virtuous, or I’ll never cheaper her; fair, or I’ll never
look on her; mild, or come not near me; noble, or not I for an angel;
of good discourse, an excellent musician, and her hair shall be of what
color it please God.”
(p. 135, The Complete Works, William Shakespeare)
Their friends decide to play a trick on them. They will, by the power of suggestion, create a marriage between the two. They plan to allow Benedick and Beatrice to overhear their separate conversations, talking of the love they have for one another. As Benedick listens to his friends talk about Beatrice’s “love” for him, his heart begins to change.
“…I never did think to marry…they say the lady is fair; ‘tis a truth…
and virtuous, ‘tis so…and wise, but for loving me;…I will be horribly
in love with her. I may chance have some odd quirks and remnants of
wit broken on me because I have railed so long against marriage;
but doth not the appetite alter?...When I said I would die a bachelor, I
did not think I should live till I were married. Here comes Beatrice…
I do spy some marks of love in her”
(p. 136-137, The Complete Works, William Shakespeare)
He then spends the rest of his holiday looking for clues of her love for him… a love that was simply suggested to him.
Beatrice’s friends later use the same method to trick her. Her response to this suggestion of Benedick’s love for her is a quick change of heart as well.
“Stand I condemn’d for pride, and scorn so much? Contempt, farewell!
And maiden pride, adieu!...and Benedick, love on; I will requite thee;
Taming my wild heart to thy loving hand: If thou dost love, my kindness
shall incite thee to bind our loves up in a holy band:”
(p. 138, The Complete Works, William Shakespeare)
And this from two, who swore to never marry anyone, let alone each other!!
The plan works perfectly. Thus, by using the power of suggestion, the friends have created a perception of love between the two unknowing victims.
They later confess their love to each other in secret, but deny it in open. At this point, their friends produce proof of their love for each other. Benedick responds,
“A miracle! Here’s our own hands against our hearts!
Come, I will have thee…In brief, since I do purpose to marry,
I will think nothing to any purpose that the world can say against it;
and therefore never flout at me for what I have said against it;
for man is a giddy thing and this is my conclusion.”
(p. 151, The Complete Works, William Shakespeare)
My conclusion is that man is a gullible thing. What our minds perceive will come to pass, whether it be for good or for ill and we will act upon this perception. We must be very careful playing with people’s lives. Through the power of suggestion, man can yield destruction or creation.